9 Best Mind bending movies similar to Shutter Island you should watch

Movies like shutter island

Leonardo Dicaprio’s psychological thriller Shutter Island was surely one of the most popular sinister thrillers of its time. Even today, one can rarely find a movie of its match.

Not only was Leo’s remarkable acting a reason many obsessed with this movie, but the legendary film director Martin Scorsese also gave everyone a disturbing thriller plot that stole our sleep.

If you’re also a fan of such criminal thrillers as Shutter Island, there are many movies you can explore this weekend!

Shutter island is famously known as a Hollywood ‘classic’ because of Martin’s remarkable creativity even while attempting such a thriller for the very first time. But do legends ever need practice? He is already a gifted filmmaker.

The movie is set on an island far away from where the US Marshall Teddy arrives to investigate a murder case after prolonging the case for too long. The movie revolves around Teddy’s investigation while also shedding light on the mysteries of his personal life.

It doesn’t take long for the marshall to find out what illegal and sinister activities are happening in the hospital. It isn’t only the mentally sick patients but also the doctors he finds out to be involved in crimes.

However, soon the hospital’s management restricted his investigations and limited what he could include in the case study. Mark Ruffalo here plays the role of Teddy’s friend Chuck, and Emily Mortimer plays Rachel Solando, a significant character in the movie.

If you have not watched Shetter Island, then do watch this thriller as it will twist your mind. Shutter Island is streaming on Netflix along with Prime Video, Binge, Sky Go, Fubo TV, and other streaming platforms.

List of Movies Like Shutter Island | Shutter Island Like Films

1. Changeling

movies like shutter island

This movie is a product of the famous director and filmmaker Clint Eastwood’s efforts. Featuring an elite cast like Angelina Jolie as Christine and John Malkovich as Gustav, this movie is an epic mystery that can leave you sleepless at night.

It was released in 2008, and many still think it is an underrated masterpiece. Christine is a single mother who struggles to find her young son and meets several mind-bending deceptions during the investigations.

Months later, when she is informed of a boy who looks like her son, the case is closed. LAPD is the police department dealing with her case, and they never believe her when she doesn’t agree that it’s her son.

Los Angeles soon starts protesting for the mother while she never gives up searching for her only son. The movie is a package of emotional drama and crime thrillers, just as shutter island. Among the list of movies like Shutter Island, we rank this one first and foremost.

Where to Watch Changeling

Changeling is streaming on a number of OTT platforms around the world.

  • In the US, you can watch this Shutter Island-like movie on HBO Max, HBO, Max Go, Direct TV, and Prime Video with the Cinemax channel addon.
  • In UK, Changeling is not streaming online anywhere. Although you can rent the movie on Chili, Amazon Video, Rakuten TV, Sky Store, and other stores.
  • In Canada, Changeling can not be watched on any streaming platform. However, you can rent the movie on Cineplex, Flix Fling, Apple iTunes, Amazon Video, and Google Play Movies.
  • In Australia, this movie is available on Netflix, Binge and Foxtel Now.

Also Read: 7 Movies like Gone Girl you should watch in 2022

2. Black Swan

Flims like shutter island

In 2010, the black swan had a dark theme similar to Shutter Island’s. It is a drama-thriller that focuses on Natalie Portman, who plays Nina Sayers, a ballerina passionate about her art. She is not only an aspiring dancer but also one widely admired.

The movie revolves around Nina and her thoughts when she has to face competition for her dancing skills.

The dance director, looking for two girls to play the ‘swans’ in his next show, finds Nina unfit for a role even after accepting her from auditions. Nina starts having hallucinations and weird dreams about being replaced. She isn’t only in a dark state of mind but also destructive.

Do you remember how the climax in Shutter Island was all about Teddy and his thoughts at the end? Well, if you like those types of movies, add this to the list! The movie also features Vincent Cassel and Winona Rider in key roles.

You know Director Darren Aronofsky has done a remarkable job when Natalie Portman wins an academy award for her acting in the movie. This movie is the best choice among movies similar to Shutter Island.

Where to Watch Black Swan

Black Swan was nominated for a number of academy awards in 2011. This Shutter Island-like movie is streaming on a number of OTT services.

  • In the United States, you can watch Black Swan only on Hulu.
  • In UK, Black Swan is available on Disney+, Prime Video, and Virgin TV Go.
  • In Canada, you can watch this movie only on Disney+
  • In Australia, Black Swan is available for streaming only on Disney Plus

Also Read: 8 Hilariously Funny Movies Like Superbad you should watch in 2022

3. Fight Club

shutter island like movies

Fight club is an action-thriller that stars Brad Pitt and Edward Norton as the main roles. This David Fincher 1999 release is surely something you would find intriguing.

While Brad is a careless person living a life that he wants to change, Tyler (Edward) is also no different, in the fact that he doesn’t take a step and has serious insomnia issues. Both become pals soon after their weird meetup as strangers.

Fight Club is where Brad teaches young boys to wrestle and trains them to fight. At first, the Club is just a random training school before turning into something darker and more dangerous.

David Fincher combines many themes effectively in the movie and leaves deep life lessons for the viewers.

Where to Watch Fight Club (1999)

Fight Club is considered to be one of the best mind-twisting movies like Shutter Island. The movie features Brad Pitt as Tyler Durden, an iconic performance by the actor which is still cherished and remembered. You can watch Fight Club on the following streaming platforms:

  • In the US, Fight Club can be streamed on Tubi TV, Direct TV, Sling TV, TNT, TBS, Spectrum on Demand and Tru TV.
  • In Australia, luckily you can watch Fight Club on Netflix, Prime Video and Disney+
  • In Canada, this Shutter Island-like movie can be watched on Crave (Starz) and Prime Video with Starz channel addon.
  • In the United Kingdom, you can watch Fight Club on Netflix, Prime Video, Virgin TV Go and Disney+

4. Memento

movies similar to shutter island

Memento is a 2001 classic mystery-thriller genre movie remade even in Bollywood. Christopher Nolan didn’t have a smooth plotline for this one, but he also worked the hardest.

Guy Pearce plays Leonard Shelby’s leading role, a patient with anterograde amnesia searching for the killer of his wife. More than a tragic lover seeking vengeance, this movie is a psychological thriller that develops a whole narrative.

With tattoos drawn and notes written all over his body, Lenny looks like a sociopath with anger issues and emotional disorders. If you are a fan of movies that play with the mind and offer a climax that makes two ends meet smoothly, Memento is a masterpiece.

Memento has just the level of mystery that we saw in Shutter Island. The movie was released in 2001 in the USA and earned a huge box office of 40 million dollars quickly.

Where to Watch Memento (2000)

Memento was the first movie by the famous director Christopher Nolan. The movie keeps you mind busy analyzing what is happening. The movie can be watched on the following platforms.

  • In the United States, you can watch this Shutter Island-like film on HBO Max, HBO, Hoopla, Kanopy, Direct TV, Spectrum on Demand.
  • In UK, Memento can be streamed on BBC iPlayer for Free and on Virgin TV Go.
  • In Australia, Memento is not available on any streaming service. you can rent the movie on Fetch for $8.99.
  • In Canada, Memento can be watched on Prime Video and Hoopla.

Also Read: Where to watch Jurrasic Park (all movies) online in 2022

5. Get Out

flims similar to memento

Get Out is a horror movie that combines many deep themes into one movie and is analyzed by so many people for the scary symbols and imagery it contains. Get Out is one of the movies like Shutter Island that are more horror-like.

Jordan Peele starts with the problems being a black American can have. Visiting his girlfriend’s house for the first time, Chris is nervous and excited at the same time.

Although the couple faces an accident on the way, everything seems to be normal on the surface at first. Little did the couple know that the most sinister depths and secrets lay in Rose’s (his girlfriend) house.

Her parents seem suspicious to Chris at first, but he is soon trapped deep enough that he can “get out” as quickly as he got in.

Where to Watch Get Out (2017)

You can watch Get Out on the following streaming Platforms.

  • In the United States, Get Out is only available for rent. you can rent the movie on Apple iTunes, Amazon Videos, Google Play Movies, Vudu and other stores.
  • In Australia, the movie is streaming on Binge and Foxtel Now.
  • In Canada, this Shutter Island like movie is not streaming on Crave or Netflix. However, you can rent the movie on Cineplex, Apple iTunes, Illico, YouTube and other renting stores.
  • In the UK, you can watch Get Out only on Virgin TV Go

Also Read: 7 movies you should watch if you loved Inception

6. Mulholland Drive

shutter island like movies

David Lynch put all his effort and creativity into Mulholland Drive, a thriller featuring Naomi Watts and Laura Elena Harring. Harring, who plays Rita, faces a weird accident after which she forgets her identity and many facts related to her life.

She turns paranoid and doesn’t know a thing while wandering around Los Angeles, a city of both lights and darkness. She meets in uncertain circumstances with an aspiring actress Betty who came to Hollywood to pursue her dreams.

Betty helps Rita figure out her messed state of mind and their relationship develops in the movie while the mysteries are solved. The movie is rated 8/10 on IMDb and is surely one of the greatest thriller movies of all time.

Where to Watch Get Out (2001)

Mulholland Drive is known for its mind-boggling story and the famous lesbian scene. The movie is available on multiple streaming platforms.

  • In the United States, you can watch Mulholland Drive only on Criterion Channel
  • In UK, Mulholland Drive can be streamed on BFI Player and Virgin TV Go.
  • In Australia, you can watch this Shutter Island-like film only on Stan
  • Canadian streamers can watch Mulholland Drive on Crave (Starz), Criterion Channel, and Prime Video (Starz add-on)

Also Read: 7 Psychological Horror Movies Like Hereditary That Will Blow Away Your Mind

7. Jacob’s Ladder

Flims similar to shutter island

This movie is surely an underrated psychological thriller with a plot that will blow your mind. Jacob’s ladder focuses on themes like thriller, family, and horror. We recommend you to check out the older version of this movie which was released in the 90s.

If you want to add that to your watchlist, it is also a top among Shutter Island films. The 2019 movie is much more developed not only in plot but also in direction. Michael Ealy in the 2019 film plays the role of the protagonist Jacob Singer while Jesse Williams plays Jacob’s brother Isaac Singer.

Jacob’s mind slips into paranoia when he realizes his brother might be in danger the can’t fathom. The movie begins with the death of Isaac Singer, which is tragic but a normal death.

However, when Jacob finds out that his brother might not be dead or maybe didn’t die the way he saw it, everything begins to question itself, and sinister consequences follow.

Where to Watch Get Out (2019)

  • In US, you can watch Jacob’s Ladder on Hoopla and Tubi TV.
  • In Canada, the movie can be streamed only on Hoopla.
  • In the United Kingdom, this shutter Island-like movie can be watched on Prime Video and Virgin TV Go.
  • In Australia, this movie is not available for streaming, however, you can rent the movie on Amazon Prime, Google Play Movies, Fetch, Apple iTunes and Fetch.

8. The Prestige

shutter island similar movies

The 2006 Nolan movie Prestige is a serious drama that adopts a fun theme of magic and tragedy. With a legendary cast like Christian Bale, Michael Caine, Scarlett Johanson, and Hugh Jackman, this movie is a luxury gift to Hollywood cinema.

It focuses on how magicians fool the world from a surface while magic can be as deep and dangerous as anything else. Magic tricks are more than just fooling the mind. They are games of the masters.

And when turned dark and evil, magic can be the eeriest of rivalries. This movie is about passion, fame, love, and, most importantly, sacrifice.

Where to The Prestige (2006)

The Prestige is one of our top recommended mind-bending movies of all time. Loaded with a super cast like Cristian Bale (The Dark Knight) and Huge Jackman (Wolwareen), this movie will twist your mind as Shutter Island did.

  • In the US, you can watch it only on Prime Video.
  • In Australia this Shutter Island-like movie is streaming on Netflix, Binge, Foxtel Now, and Stan (4K)
  • In the United Kingdom, you can watch The Prestige on Prime Video and Virgin TV Go.
  • In Canada, you can stream this movie only on Disney Plus.

9. Inception

inception netflix

Christopher Nolan’s Inception is undoubtedly a masterpiece. Like every other movie by Nolan is a mix of psychological mystery and mind-games, so was Inception.

It is surely surprising if you’re a fan of psychological thrillers and you haven’t watched Inception yet. Leo plays the role of Cobb, an expert on the science of dreams.

Cobb specializes in entering a subject’s dreams and steals or plants information in their heads as clients demand. However unusual this job may sound, it is a matter of life and death, family and love for Cobb.

After losing his wife in limbo due to uncertainties in this work, Cobb is now off to a final mission that would end things once and for all. His colleagues Arthur (Joseph Gordan) and Earners (Tom Hardy) also play a significant part.

The movie has a confusing and puzzling plot that leaves many instances open to the viewer’s interpretation. Leaving key questions unanswered is Nolan’s specialty.

The never-ending debates Nolan’s movies leave behind are sure as artistic as anything else. So if you’re ready for yet another epic and puzzling performance by Leonardo DiCaprio, add this movie next on your list.

Where to Inception (2010)

Inception is streaming on Netflix and other OTT platforms. Here is a list of streaming platforms through which you can watch this mind-bending movie like Shutter Island.

  • In the US, you can watch Inception only on HBO Max.
  • In UK, this Shutter Island-like movie is available on Sky Go, Now TV Cinema, and Virgin TV Go
  • In Canada, you can stream Inception on Netflix, Crave, Club Illico, and Prime Video (with Starz Play Channel)
  • Australian streamers can stream the movie on Binge, Foxtel Now, and Stan (4K)


Horror and thriller movies are surely an addiction once you get into them. These movies are not only masterpieces but also a must-have for your watchlist if you’re searching for movies similar to Shutter Island. So don’t wait for the next weekend; add to your list right now!

Written by Mickel Clark

Mickel is a streaming aficionado who loves nothing more than to pen down his thoughts about the movies, anime and TV shows he has watched and likes sharing hacks on how to stream them online.